Which? Reviews
Tried & Tested: Slug and Snail Control Products

Tried & Tested: Slug and Snail Control Products

Slugs and snails are serious pests in most gardens at certain times of year. A square metre may contain 60 slugs and, under ideal conditions, as many as 200. These are mostly the secretive kind that lives underground, rather than the big ones that blunder about above ground. So, even if you go out every night to collect and dispose of all you can see, you'll only scratch the surface. And, because nature abhors a vacuum, even if you do manage to kill every slug in your garden, more will move in from next door. If you garden on alkaline soil, snails can be numerous, too. They are nocturnal surface dwellers but tend to commute each evening from dark, damp hiding places under paving, in crevices or under hedges. It isn't feasible to eliminate slugs and snails altogether, but you can protect valuable plants, deter them from some areas and minimise their impact. Gardening Which? carried out extensive tests on a range of control methods. Here are their findings...

The control methods tested were chemical repellents and solid, granular and other barriers. Slug killers rely on the poison metaldehyde, which causes dehydration. There have been concerns about the effect of this and of poisoned slugs and snails on wildlife, and some gardeners prefer not to use them. Barriers physically prevent pests reaching vulnerable plants and avoid the need to kill them. They include plastic collars, copper bands, gels, dry powders and sharp granules. Regardless of which you use, Gardening Which? says it is better to focus on protecting vulnerable plants and clearing smaller areas, thus giving plants a chance to grow big enough to cope with slug and snail attack.

For inspirational ideas coupled with reliable, research-based information subscribe to Gardening Which?. To receive three issues of Gardening Which? for just £3, visit www.which.co.uk/gardening. Please note, although all of the products have been tested, Which? has not tested the quality of service from the suppliers mentioned below.
Bio Slug Mini Pellets 1kg, £9.95 inc p&p

Bio Slug Mini Pellets 1kg, £9.95 inc p&p

For larger areas or many plants, and used sensibly, slug pellets containing metaldehyde can’t be beaten on effectiveness or cost.

Available from: Greenfingers Trading
Slug Rings, 6 x 10cm rings, £14 inc p&p (other packs available)

Slug Rings, 6 x 10cm rings, £14 inc p&p (other packs available)

If you have only a few plants in the ground to protect, these are worth the investment. They come in two sizes, 10cm and 17.5cm diameter, in slug-averse copper.

Available from: Slugrings.co.uk
Hosta Haloes, pack of 6, £9.99 inc p&p

Hosta Haloes, pack of 6, £9.99 inc p&p

Like slug rings, these plastic collars, with their almost impermeable overhang, remain in place for a whole season and should last for many years.

Available from: Green Gardener
Agralan Copper Snail & Slug Tape £11.94 inc p&p

Agralan Copper Snail & Slug Tape £11.94 inc p&p

Prevent slugs and snails from climbing up to eat plants in pots with a continuous band of this serrated repellant tape.

Available from: Gardening Naturally
 
 

Sky Channel 248, Virgin TV 267
Gardens On TV Now

Gardens  All UKTV